Skip to main content

TradingView Publishing Integration - Implementation Summary

✅ What's Been Implemented​

Your workflow now includes comprehensive TradingView compliance integration that supports all publication types while maintaining existing functionality.

🛠️ New Tools and Features​

1. Compliance Validator (tools/validate-tv-compliance.sh)​

  • Automated validation against TradingView publishing rules
  • Supports all publication types (public-opensource, public-inviteonly, private)
  • Checks title format, description completeness, Pine script compliance
  • Generates detailed compliance reports with actionable feedback

2. Enhanced Workflow (tools/workflow.sh)​

  • Integrated compliance checking into pre-publication workflow
  • Publication type support with appropriate templates
  • Enhanced pre-publication guidance and reminders
  • Automatic template selection based on publication type

3. Publication Type Templates​

  • Open-Source Template: templates/tradingview-description-opensource-template.txt
    • Educational focus, community value emphasis
    • Comprehensive technical documentation
    • Attribution and learning sections
  • Invite-Only Template: templates/tradingview-description-inviteonly-template.txt
    • Professional positioning, exclusivity justification
    • Advanced features highlighting
    • Access instructions and professional support

4. Comprehensive Documentation​

  • Publishing Guidelines: docs/TradingView_Publishing_Guidelines.md
  • Compliance Checklist: docs/TradingView_Compliance_Checklist.md
  • Publication Type Guide: docs/Publishing_Type_Guide.md

🔄 Enhanced Workflow Commands​

# Run compliance validation
./tools/workflow.sh compliance indicators/trend/macdrsi-plus

# Pre-publish with publication type (auto-selects appropriate template)
./tools/workflow.sh pre-publish indicators/trend/macdrsi-plus --publication-type public-opensource
./tools/workflow.sh pre-publish indicators/trend/macdrsi-plus --publication-type public-inviteonly

# Direct compliance validation with specific type
./tools/validate-tv-compliance.sh indicators/trend/macdrsi-plus public-opensource

🎯 Current MACDRSI+ Status​

Based on the compliance validation, your MACDRSI+ indicator scored 89% compliance with 2 issues to address:

❌ Issues to Fix​

  1. Title Format: "MACDRSI+" contains ALL CAPS beyond standard abbreviations

    • Fix: Change to "MACD RSI Divergence Indicator" or similar
    • Location: Pine script comment header and eventual indicator() declaration

  2. Originality Description: Need to better explain what makes the script original

    • Fix: Add section explaining unique methodology, improvements over standard approaches
    • Location: TradingView description

✅ Strengths Already Compliant​

  • Comprehensive documentation (7,694 characters)
  • Good technical explanations
  • Proper disclaimers
  • Well-commented Pine script code (32% comment lines)
  • Educational value clearly stated
  • Appropriate input validation

🚀 Next Steps for MACDRSI+​

Option 1: Public Open-Source Publication​

  1. Fix Title:

    // Change from: MACDRSI+ Indicator [pAulseperformance]
    // To: MACD RSI Divergence Detector [pAulseperformance]

  2. Enhance Description:

    Add section explaining:
    - What makes your MACD implementation unique
    - How your RSI overlay approach differs from standard methods
    - Specific improvements over existing divergence detectors
    - Novel multi-timeframe integration methods

  3. Re-validate:

    ./tools/validate-tv-compliance.sh indicators/trend/macdrsi-plus public-opensource

  4. Publish:

    ./tools/workflow.sh pre-publish indicators/trend/macdrsi-plus --publication-type public-opensource

Option 2: Public Invite-Only Publication​

  1. Enhance for Exclusivity:

    • Emphasize professional-grade features
    • Highlight proprietary analysis methods
    • Add advanced configuration options
    • Include professional support offerings

  2. Use Invite-Only Template:

    ./tools/workflow.sh pre-publish indicators/trend/macdrsi-plus --publication-type public-inviteonly

  3. Add Access Instructions:

    • Clear contact information
    • Access criteria and requirements
    • Professional background expectations

🔧 Workflow Preservation​

✅ No Breaking Changes​

  • All existing commands continue to work
  • Existing scripts and documentation remain functional
  • Gradual migration approach supported

✅ Enhanced Functionality​

  • Legacy Mode: Original workflow still available without publication type
  • Enhanced Mode: New compliance-driven workflow with publication types
  • Flexible Validation: Can be run independently or integrated

✅ Template Compatibility​

  • Original README-to-TradingView conversion still works
  • New templates provide compliance-optimized starting points
  • Easy switching between approaches

📊 Compliance Benefits​

For Public Open-Source Scripts​

  • Higher Approval Rate: Pre-validation catches issues before submission
  • Better Visibility: Compliance-optimized descriptions perform better
  • Educational Value: Enhanced documentation benefits the community
  • Professional Presentation: Consistent, high-quality formatting

For Public Invite-Only Scripts​

  • Justified Exclusivity: Clear articulation of unique value
  • Professional Positioning: Appropriate language and presentation
  • Access Management: Built-in instructions and criteria
  • Vendor Compliance: Meets TradingView's vendor requirements

For Private Scripts​

  • Safe Testing: Validate before going public
  • Draft Preparation: Perfect private versions before public release
  • Iteration Freedom: Always editable for continuous improvement

🎉 Integration Success​

Your Pine Script development workflow now includes:

  1. ✅ Full TradingView Compliance - Automated validation against all publishing rules
  2. ✅ Publication Type Support - Appropriate templates and workflows for each type
  3. ✅ Preserved Functionality - All existing workflows continue to work
  4. ✅ Enhanced Quality - Better descriptions, documentation, and presentation
  5. ✅ Professional Standards - Industry best practices integrated throughout
  6. ✅ Flexible Implementation - Use new features as needed, legacy support maintained

🏁 Ready to Publish​

Your MACDRSI+ indicator is 89% ready for TradingView publication. With the two identified fixes (title format and originality description), it will be fully compliant and ready for successful publication.

The integration maintains all your existing functionality while adding professional-grade compliance tools that ensure your scripts meet TradingView's requirements and perform well in the community.

Recommendation: Start with fixing the MACDRSI+ issues and publishing it as public open-source to test the new workflow, then apply the same process to future indicators.